Thanks for the additional info! (Thank you both for responding, btw) I did some additional digging online and confirmed that Con Edison Solutions is the ESCO arm of Con Edison. Why the utility has an ESCO is a mystery. In any event, during my digging, I found this useful website that lists current pricing as well as pricing history (by month, going back several years!) for Con Edison and the ESCOs in NYS.
http://www.newyorkpowertochoose.com/ptc_choose.cfm?CFID=1002707&CFTOKEN=27447549 Assuming that the rates listed are accurate, I compared my monthly 2013 rates per kWh to the rates listed for Con Edison and found Con Edison Solutions overall had lower rates in 2013. However, my 2014 monthly rates were a lot higher.
Based on the chart, some of the current ESCO rates look pretty attractive, but I'm also wary of hidden fees and low intro rates that disappear after 2 months. The pricing chart only tells you who's cheaper but not their reputations.
I'm thinking of ditching my ESCO and going back to Con Edison (not even sure how I got into the ESCO to begin with), but would like to hear from anyone who would recommend their ESCO as an alternative and also has competitive rates with Con Edison. Thanks so much in advance for your input!