Author Topic: dirty & Stinky 73th street  (Read 12366 times)

Offline I live here too

  • Mayor
  • *******
  • Posts: 630
    • View Profile
Re: dirty & Stinky 73th street
« Reply #30 on: August 25, 2011, 06:44:28 PM »
I was thrilled to see this article re the folks at Sheila Terrace and would be even more thrilled to see Co-op, Condo, Private Home and Renters band together and make our voices heard regarding quality of life issues in JH heard. I'm going to call Peralta's office.

Offline toddg

  • Moderator
  • Mayor
  • *******
  • Posts: 3492
    • View Profile
  • Lived here since: 2002
Re: dirty & Stinky 73th street
« Reply #31 on: August 25, 2011, 10:43:53 PM »
On the bright side, as of today, hopefully 73rd Street has slightly less traffic.   Soon the buses will be gone, too.

Offline EvaViva

  • Tourist
  • **
  • Posts: 14
    • View Profile
Re: dirty & Stinky 73th street
« Reply #32 on: September 01, 2011, 01:04:01 AM »
Hmm...I had to think long and hard about the issues at hand here and here is my humble opinion:

I am sorry that the people of Sheila Terrace feel like their street has changed but the truth is, in an urban environment, neighborhoods and streets can change over time.  That's what happens. 

Now, there should definitely be steps taken to help clean up the area.  Perhaps an alliance can be forged with the vendors and the business owners to take care of the area.  A meeting should be held with all parties present.  If there are complaint meetings, how can cooperation be expected.

But I feel uneasy to think that what I am hearing is essentially people saying that they have more of a right to the street than the other people who occupy it.  The business owners and their customers have just as much of a right to be there.  It might be too "exotic" for some people but honestly, as someone else mentioned before, it's one of the best things about the neighborhood.  I live on 73rd between 37th and 35th so almost of all my visitors come down 73rd to see me.  Everyone loves the area--the sights, the smells, the sounds.  I happen to love seeing the street vendors and all the crazy sights and sounds.  I love that these stores are open late or 24 hours--I feel safe when I walk home late at night.  It is what makes New York City great--these people made a street their own. 

It might be nice to have everything be white-washed and so-called historic but this is New York City!  There are plenty of "clean," gentrified blocks to move to, if needed...

Offline EvaViva

  • Tourist
  • **
  • Posts: 14
    • View Profile
Re: dirty & Stinky 73th street
« Reply #33 on: September 01, 2011, 01:12:11 AM »
"I understand that they have different standard in terms of cleaness but they have to realize that the street is shared by people from other cultures and they can't force their standard to the public street.   "

Like the above quote is kinda ugly..."They" have different standards of cleanliness?   

Also what was said about "Season's Greetings, everyone"--  Why is it such a bother to you if some people put up a "Season's Greetings" sign?  And who knows who paid for that sign or how it was paid for? 

As long as you regard your ethnic neighbors as being second-class citizens with no standards, you're not going to get anywhere.  A little respect in terms of discourse might go a long way and might lead to productive collaboration in cleaning up the neighborhood.  You can attract a lot more bees with honey, my friends.


Offline ShinjukuBaby

  • Council Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 268
    • View Profile
Re: dirty & Stinky 73th street
« Reply #34 on: September 01, 2011, 04:06:04 AM »
Quote
But I feel uneasy to think that what I am hearing is essentially people saying that they have more of a right to the street than the other people who occupy it.  The business owners and their customers have just as much of a right to be there.

I appreciate your post, but to be honest, I don't know why you think you're hearing that, because that's not what people seem to me to be saying at all.

I think the point is that we are all in this neighborhood together.  Some people, however, don't seem to be acting like good neighbors.  Everybody should feel welcome to shop and socialize, but that doesn't mean that people have the right to leave filthy, unsanitary conditions.  Nor do they have the right to blast music outside of somebody's apartment at midnight or urinate on the sidewalk.  Dealing drugs is not acceptable behavior.  It's not "yuppie" or "whitewashing" to expect people to adhere to basic standards of conduct.

I like the street vendors and I patronize them and other businesses on 73rd.  However, I wouldn't dream of doing something on somebody else's block that I wouldn't want done on mine.  I don't think that's too much to ask of people.

Offline NYC Peromyscus

  • Council Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 347
    • View Profile
Re: dirty & Stinky 73th street
« Reply #35 on: September 01, 2011, 07:00:30 AM »
Evaviva, you didn't go to the meeting so I'm afraid your comments don't reflect reality.  That meeting included at least 50 people representing every ethnic group in Jackson Heights (and they weren't just from Sheila Terrace, also from Birchwood House across the street), including Bangladeshis and Indians that are fed up with folks trashing the street.  Some of the business owners are also fed up because the problem-makers just buy one cup of tea and hang out blocking their entrances all night, not to mention the congestion from too much circling traffic and competition from illegal vendors.

What we are talking about here is a half-block in an otherwise wonderful neighborhood where anything is allowed.  Businesses and both illegal and legal vendors appropriate much more of the sidewalk than they are permitted.  Huge illuminated signs are left on all night, even when businesses are closed. People throw trash anywhere they want (and it is more than just an issue of trashcans; people throw things on the ground within sight of trashcans that are not full). 

People loiter until the early morning hours yelling, blasting music, and smoking outside apt windows near street level.  There are also people dealing drugs and getting wasted behind the cell phone store.  Mattresses are thrown in the alley for sex.  And on and on.

Let's face it.  If one-tenth of what goes on along this half block were happening in the precious historic district, the cops would be all over it.  If the folks trashing the street and loitering all night were black or hispanic rather than South Asian the cops would be all over it (not saying that is right, just pointing out the double standard).  Look at the over-reaction to a little soccer celebrating on 37th Avenue.  We get no reaction on 73rd St.  Two auxiliary cops walking around would eliminate most problems very quickly.

Danny Dromm has sent a letter to the residents of the block encouraging a 311 campaign, followed by calling their office with the reference number so they can follow up.  They also encourage a block association, which hopefully we can get going so that the several hundreds of residents of Sheila and Birchwood can have their interests represented alongside the businesses that increasingly control 73rd St.

P.S. We have the right to complain on this board.  The "Seasons Greetings" decorations are the same tacky crap that are put up in Little Italy to appeal to tourists.  One of the support poles actually fell over during the meeting mentioned above.

Offline NYC Peromyscus

  • Council Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 347
    • View Profile
Re: dirty & Stinky 73th street
« Reply #36 on: September 01, 2011, 07:04:40 AM »
Another thing that was mentioned by many people at the meeting: physical intimidation by the vendors.  Many residents of Sheila Terrace tried approaching them with concerns and were immediately surrounded by vendors from multiple carts and tables in a threatening manner.  Some movers that were bringing furniture into Birchwood had to call the police on one occasion due to threats (I witnessed this one myself...particularly ugly as they were along the lines of "I'm a Muslim and you don't know what I could do to you".

It doesn't work to bring individual concerns...we need collective action.

Offline I live here too

  • Mayor
  • *******
  • Posts: 630
    • View Profile
Re: dirty & Stinky 73th street
« Reply #37 on: September 01, 2011, 12:29:29 PM »
I live in the "precious historic district" on 37th Avenue.  Perhaps it's not quite as bad as 73rd street (which seems to have it's own unique set of problems) but I guarantee you that the "precious historic district" is NOT getting any special treatment or attention.  Garbage overflows from cans, retailers blast music out into the street and those horrible LED signs glow all night.  If things are a little better it's because the residential buildings take care of their properties and the areas in front of them.  For that matter 82nd street is in the historic district and you see what a train wreck that's become.  Seriously I wish some posters on this site would can it with the anti-"gentrification" and anti-ownership rants.  My husband and I own our apartment, went to college but are far from "The Man" people in JH are so desperately afraid of.  I work 12-14 hour days to pay my bills and shop at costco just like the rest of you. We invested in the neighborhood by buying our apartments, serving on our building's board, shopping at local stores and using local services and making friends with our neighbors.

Offline NYC Peromyscus

  • Council Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 347
    • View Profile
Re: dirty & Stinky 73th street
« Reply #38 on: September 01, 2011, 12:45:42 PM »
"I live here too", I don't think anyone on this thread is anti-ownership.  The meeting was organized by coop shareholders in two buildings on 73rd St, many of whom have owned ever since the buildings went coop.  Only in the last few years have things really become out of hand on 73rd St...the owners in these buildings and their neighbors have always had good relations but now they are deteriorating.  The whole point is to get back to some harmony.  Feelings might be hurt along the way, but that is life.

Compare to 74th St, which is more vibrant and interesting in a lot of ways but cleaner and quiets down after 11 PM.  As was expressed at the meeting, 73rd St residents would love to have something approaching the 74th St situation.  How do we make that happen?

Yes, 82nd St has problems, but the 82nd St block between 37th Ave and Roosevelt is almost all commercial.  There are not several hundred residents on that block as on 73rd.  82nd St also has a police officer assigned to patrol...rare is the day you will see a cop on 73rd, even driving through.

Offline EvaViva

  • Tourist
  • **
  • Posts: 14
    • View Profile
Re: dirty & Stinky 73th street
« Reply #39 on: September 01, 2011, 12:46:20 PM »
I see--I didn't realize the situation was that bad.  I never saw the cell phone store house area so I concur that it has to be stopped.  I'm glad the meeting had representation from a lot of parties.  I hope this gets resolved and the streets get cleaned up-literally and figuratively-soon!

I hail from an Italian background but my sister-in-law (who I am very close with) is a Bangladeshi Muslim.  We're both really surprised that people would say, "I'm Muslim and you don't know what I can do to you" to people, especially in light of the fact that a lot of Muslims feel really afraid all the time.  NYC Peromyscus, I sort of think that you make sweeping blanket statements about things in the neighborhood that can appear to border on racism and bigotry.  I am not sure if you harbor some sort of inner dislike for the ethnic population of 73rd street, etc. (as a viewing of your history of comments would seem to indicate) or if that is just my perception.  I apologize if I am perceiving your comments incorrectly and I do hope that is the case.  It is a little bizarre to me that many people would come up and "I'm a Muslim and you don't know what I can to you" sort of comments as well as I think it is bizarre that multiple people have "coughed" in your face on 73rd street.  I have lived here for 7 years now as have many close friends.  We were all looking at this board together last night over some wine and, frankly, your Jackson Heights experiences seem a bit exaggerated and propelled by what might be a dislike of the ethnic populations that inhabit corners of Jackson Heights.  Like I've always said, we should definitely clean things up and make the neighborhood as beautiful and nice as possible but if you're looking for a gentrified block with "controlled exoticness," this might not be it for you...

I seriously am not trying to offend anyone here--I totally see your point of view, residents.  Action should be taken.  As a resident of 73rd street, I would like to see things being cleaner too.  I just think that calling signs "tacky" or commenting on hygienic habits of a group of people is a little ugly.  Think about what you are saying and why you might be saying it...

Offline NYC Peromyscus

  • Council Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 347
    • View Profile
Re: dirty & Stinky 73th street
« Reply #40 on: September 01, 2011, 12:56:01 PM »
The "I'm a Muslim" comment was made by one individual to another individual...I saw it happen.  You can believe or not believe.  I think the signs are tacky...they are Christmas decorations that were repurposed.  I don't like cheap Christmas decorations.  My post about people coughing in my face is an observation...I have also narrowly missed being spat upon on multiple occasions.  My opinion is that one should cover one's mouth when coughing on the street, and not spit in proximity to others (or at all on the street unless you can't help it).

My family is half south Asian and it's  a big reason why we live in the neighborhood.  Your accusation of racism is ridiculous.  Multiculturalism has jumped the rails when one can't criticize public cleanliness without the race card being pulled.

Offline bryncellen

  • Citizen
  • ****
  • Posts: 58
    • View Profile
Re: dirty & Stinky 73th street
« Reply #41 on: September 01, 2011, 02:56:10 PM »
In some ways, it’s a little hard to assess how serious this problem is. I totally understand complaints about things like loud noise very late at night when people are trying to sleep and accumulated garbage.   

On the other hand, I don’t see how holiday decorations -- however “tacky” -- are a serious concern.  It’s just part of the neighborhood mix.
Also -- being coughed on is obviously not pleasant but it is something that inevitably happens in a city like NY, whether in Jackson Heights or elsewhere.  I pass along 73rd Street every so often and have never noticed a major problem -- but I guess if I was living there I might have a different view point. 

Have to say, though, I don’t see any real problem on 82nd Street, which is close to home and which I walk along every day  (don’t understand why 82nd Street would ever be considered a train wreck as someone said above).   

Offline Queenskid

  • Council Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 267
    • View Profile
Re: dirty & Stinky 73th street
« Reply #42 on: September 01, 2011, 03:42:15 PM »
EvaViva, I think your points are lost when you use this coded "race card" language:

It might be too "exotic" for some people
It might be nice to have everything be white-washed
There are plenty of "clean," gentrified blocks to move to, if needed...
if you're looking for a gentrified block with "controlled exoticness,"


This seems more designed to put people you disagree with back on their heels than anything else.  To me, this is about respect, pure and simple.  What I see on 73rd Street isn't the product of race or ethnicity, it's the result of people who don't show any respect for our community.  If you live here, you shouldn't be using our streets as a garbage can.  If you are visiting, you shouldn't be using our streets as a garbage can.  And if I criticize the people who treat our community as a garbage dump, it's not because they are too "exotic" for me, or because I want to "white-wash" the neighborhood, it's because it's the right thing to do.

Offline EvaViva

  • Tourist
  • **
  • Posts: 14
    • View Profile
Re: dirty & Stinky 73th street
« Reply #43 on: September 01, 2011, 03:45:48 PM »
Trash, littering, illicit activities, drug dealing, urinating, etc: NEED TO BE ADDRESSED AND HALTED.  Totally not acceptable.

Random comments about "threatening" street vendors (the majority of whom seem to be extremely elderly men over the age of 65) on 73rd, tacky ethnic decorations, being supposedly consistently spat on and coughed at, limiting store hours to your liking: I'm not so sure how productive or valid these are in terms of complaints and battles.  

Welcome to NYC, folks.  There's always Greendale, Wisconsin if you want it to be tailor-made to your liking.  That's my home-town and I left it because everything was too perfect--the stores close at 8pm promptly, everyone's lawn is perfectly mowed, almost everyone looks and acts the same and the sidewalk is clean enough to eat off of.  

Speaking of the very threatening and hateful street vendors that are mentioned, I notice that some of the elderly men physically haul their street carts with much difficulty.  One of the men hauls it up 73rd street every early afternoon and it takes him so long to get his cart there that it's hard to watch.  He has to take long rests.  I once bought an incense holder from him and asked him why he does it every day; he said he needs it to pay his room share rent because no one will hire him because he's so old.  He's not an illegal immigrant, just a green card holder who apparently left a very poor village in Bangladesh.  He was so horribly threatening to me that at the end of our conversation, he gave me free beads (like rosary or something).  So remember that some of these people are just trying to make a living.  By some turn of fate, we were born into situations where we are coop share-holders and have time, money and ability to post on this board.  Any one of us could have easily been in that old man's shoes.  And no, he didn't spit on me or threaten to destroy me in some Muslim way at the end our conversation.

Offline EvaViva

  • Tourist
  • **
  • Posts: 14
    • View Profile
Re: dirty & Stinky 73th street
« Reply #44 on: September 01, 2011, 03:56:04 PM »
Sorry for offending anyone--I just want the discussion to focus on the issues at hand--like the things that matter.  I think we're going to lose this battle if we start tacking on questionable personal offendings and posting things that I find hard to believe happened.  I don't think I'm being unreasonable.  I want to see this street be clean, safe and comfortable for ALL parties.

If I pulled the race card then y'all pulled the "you pulled the race card" card.  I just want the discussion to be balanced and focused.