10
« on: February 11, 2011, 11:33:50 AM »
With all due respect to the staff and board at the Garden School, as well as the students and the parents, I have to agree with Dudley.
The Garden School has a lot going for it. It is part of our community’s history. It has a great after school program in the arts and music. By all accounts, students and parents do feel like an extended family.
But over the years, the Garden School has made the decision to, on many levels, set itself apart from the larger community. More recent educational institutions, such as the Renaissance School and 82nd Street Academics have integrated themselves into the fabric of the community through linkages and partnerships and activities that reflect a concern not only for their students and their families, but also for the larger community.
The Garden School, it seems, has not even looked at the changing demographics of the neighborhood in recent years, and recognized that the influx of more middle class and upper middle class families with young children should be bringing them lots of business. Instead, they prefer to reach out to Manhattan families and families from more affluent Queens and Brooklyn neighborhoods, who find them more economical than Manhattan private schools.
When my daughter was 2, I took a tour of their preschool, and seriously considered it as an option for the following year. The program looked great. But I was baffled by the fact that they did not run a UPK program for 4 year olds. Why would I pay for something that should be free for all NY kids? Many active, involved parents who plan carefully for their children’s education start looking at quality UPK programs at least a year or two in advance. I wanted to send my 3 year old to the school where she would attend UPK (plus extended day, paid for out of pocked) as a 4 year old. Why would the Garden School decide to exclude that huge pool of parents? It seems to me that a quality UPK program would not only bring money into the school for the kids attending UPK, but would also bring families into the school, a percentage of whom would undoubtedly decide to keep their kids there for kindergarten, and perhaps even through high school!
In a neighborhood in which all of the other schools are bursting at the seems, why is the Garden School having low enrollment and financial problems? I believe that for many many years, they have dismissed the surrounding Jackson Heights community. And I believe that their recent actions demonstrate that they intend to continue to dismiss the community.
Actually, it is worse than that. They have alienated the community that should be filling their classrooms.
As I research kindergartens for my daughter to attend next September, most of my first choices are schools with crazy competitive lotteries. Renaissance accepted 40 students out of 1400 applications last year. We will apply. We probably won’t get in.
Up until a few weeks ago, the Garden School was my backup. My “safety school.†If my daughter did not get into any of the other schools that we are applying to, I could figure out a way to pay the tuition at the Garden School.
At this point, I am so mad at the Garden School, that I no longer consider them an option. And I’ve spoken with quite a few parents of Sept 2011 kindergarteners who feel the same way.
As Dudley said, their behavior is “bizarre and inexplicable.†Unless they plan to sell out once the Race to the Top money, (which will create 64 new charter schools in 2012) starts flowing.